Sunday, April 23, 2017

Apple #743: How Do Birds Sing?

I have to be honest. It isn't just the insanity that has accompanied the new president that has thrown me off my Appling horse, it is also my job.  I have a (relatively) new boss, and he has changed a ton of things about our department, and my workload has tripled.  Where I used to be able to finish all my work ahead of schedule and under budget with great attention to detail, now I am scrambling just to complete all the tasks I'm responsible for.  Most days I leave work late, exhausted, and dissatisfied because I have to leave things incomplete.  I haven't had much time or energy left over for much else.

This past week was an especially grueling one.  I was working on one project that I knew would be complicated.  Most projects of this kind typically take me about 5 hours.  I expected this one to take me a day, maybe day & a half.  It took a week and a half total, the final 3 days of which I spent solely and completely on it with my entire attention for a solid 8 hours, or 9 hours, or 10 hours.

At the end of one of these days, I was staggering out of my building and the sun was going down, but I was pleased because most of the time when I leave work it is dark.  I had that weird floating feeling you get when you've had insufficient sleep for a long time, and as I walked to my car, I was staring at the clouds edged with the peach of sunset and the vivid green of the grass and the potholes in the asphalt as if I had never seen any of them before.

The clouds on that evening looked something like this, though they were smaller than this. As we learned in my Sunsets entry, no two sunsets are alike, from one location to the next, from one day to the next.
(Photo of sunset over Sydney, Australia, from Wikimedia Commons)

When I got to my parking lot, I heard a bird singing.  There is a strip of grass in between two great expanses of asphalt and along this strip of grass is a row of pine trees trying valiantly to keep growing in spite of being surrounded by almost nothing.  I don't know what kind of trees these are, actually.  They look a lot like conifers, but they lose their needles in the fall and the whole concept of deciduous conifers just confuses me.  Because their needles turn brown and fall off, they look sickly most of the time.  Maybe they really are.

But it seems as though they are trying to make some sort of comeback with the spring. They are sprouting some new needles that are that very bright yellow-green of new leaves and they look soft and not stiff & pointy yet.  They are still sparse, though, so you can see the entire shape of the tree like a skeleton.

Maybe the trees in question are European larches -- one of a very few deciduous conifers.
(Photo from Go Botany)

At the very top of one of these trees sat a bird and it was singing and singing and singing.  I couldn't tell what sort of bird it was because the light was behind it so it looked like a dark shape up there.  But its song was complex, liquid, carrying, and beautiful.  It sang a series of songs, like maybe 4 patterns, then paused.  Then it sang another series of 4, but slightly different than the first 4, variations almost, then paused again.  It did this over and over, but each series I heard was different.  No pattern was exactly the same , though some of the sounds were repeated, like the way the letter "y" sounds one way when attached at the end of a word but another way when you put it at the front of a word.

To my exhausted, drained ear, it sounded beautiful and delicious.  It felt physically good to listen to it.  I wondered if I could make it my job to listen to birds' songs all day, recording their patterns.  Probably this is someone's job already, to listen to birdsongs.

I also wondered, how do birds do that?  They are such little things, how do they make a song so complex, that sounds like water bending around a curve?  Tell me more about how birds sing.

Name That Bird

  • I tried to figure out what kind of bird I heard.  The Smithsonian has a wonderful Guide to North American Bird Songs that helps you narrow down the possibilities by choosing among major identifying factors, such as whether the song has one note or two or more than that.
  • I answered several questions and got to a final list of 15 birds it could have been.  Listening to the sample clips of each one, I suppose it could have been any one of them.  It might have been a robin, or some kind of thrush, but I have never heard any robin sing quite like that before.
  • It also might have been an indigo bunting. According to the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, this bird likes to sing in the very tops of trees, and the bird I heard was doing exactly that. It's the males who sing, and they like treetops or shrubs, especially in places where shrubby roadsides meet forests.  They sing to find a mate, defend their territory, or for other reasons unknown.

  • I'm not entirely convinced it was an indigo bunting, though, because the two birds in the video above include some rough almost growly notes, and the bird I heard did not do that.  But maybe the bird I heard was different from its fellows in that way.  Birders say that birds from different parts of the country have slightly different songs, the way people have different accents in different parts of the country.

How Do They Sing Like That?

  • Birds can sing in ways that people can't because their equipment is different.  Where we have a larynx (voice box) at the top of our throats, birds have a syrinx which is situated farther down the windpipe, in their chests.
  • For us, the windpipe below the larynx meets up with the bronchial tubes which branch into two and connect to the lungs.  For birds, the syrinx is closer to the lungs, and where our larynx has one chamber, their syrinx has two.  With two chambers instead of one, naturally birds can make many more sounds than we could and they can do more complex things with the sounds, such as making two happen at once.
  • Here's another way in which the birds have us beat: we use only 2% of the air passing through our larynx to make sound. Birds use 100% of their air going through their syrinx.

A sort of big-picture diagram showing the basics of the two-chambered syrinx and where it is located within a bird
(Diagram from Heather's Site of Birding Basics)

A more zoomed-in view of the syrinx, showing the trachial and bronchial rings which line the trachea and bronchial tubes respectively, and which help create various sounds. The two red blobs on either side of the two tubes, labeled the lateral labia, are bumps of muscle, I think, which constrict the tubes or open them, and that also creates variation in sound. They can regulate volume as well as pitch.
(Diagram from Biology 342 course materials at Reed College, adapted from another source whose page is now defunct)

The Cornell Lab of Ornithology has this wonderful interactive page showing how the syrinx works and what it is doing during the songs of particular birds.  You must investigate this. Watching the interactive pages will give you a much better idea of how the whole mechanism works than any description of mine could.

But let me quote from this rather poetic passage from the British Library which explains how birds sing, and also, well, see for yourself:

As air passes, so an acoustic disturbance is set up, the tympanum vibrates and sound is created. The pitch (frequency) of that sound and the loudness (amplitude) of it can be modulated. So far as the tympanum is concerned, these two effects are usually coupled. The function of the extendable little "bump" is believed to be to change the loudness without having to change the pitch. Bear in mind that the bird may be playing at the same time a second tune on his other half; also that this description is considerably simplified. It will be clear, however that such complexity is necessary to explain the amazing vocal gymnastics certain "higher" songbirds display. "Lower" birds have a syrinx that is of a rather simpler design. In either case the physiology and acoustics of bird vocalisation are unique in the animal kingdom; further, birds produce more complex sounds than any other animal, certainly including man.

One last point: birds do not sing only when inhaling. A grasshopper warbler Locustella naevia may "reel" for over two minutes, a nightjar may chur continuously for eight minutes, and a skylark may "pour forth its full heart" in completely unbroken song for 18 minutes. To replenish their oxygen these birds must breathe in; and must do so while singing. In the case of the night jar, the bird discernibly alternates soft short trills with loud long ones and these short trills are believed to be when the bird inhales. Less continuous singers may also use air travelling in either direction. The white-rumped shama, for example, is believed so to do. (British Library)

What about Owls?

A remark in that British Library passage reminds me that I'm also curious about owls.  On other occasions, in a forest where I like to hike, I have heard barred owls hooting.  But that word "hooting" sounds really tame compared to the sounds I've heard.  The barred owl's call is typically rendered as Who cooks for you? But what I have heard was really frickin' carrying and echoing and loud.  Like you could hear this call from two miles away.  And usually it's more like Who cooks for yooooooooooou?

I have tried to duplicate this call, and every now and then other people walking in the woods have tried to call back to an actual owl. But it doesn't even come close to how full-throated the owl's call is.  Ours sounds like a weak imitation while theirs sounds like it comes from inside a barrel and gets broadcast through a megaphone.

In that British Library passage, I wonder if owls are one of the "lower" birds whose syrinx is less complex than the songbirds'.  Because for all the volume and timbre of the owl's call it is not as complex as a songbird's song.  The barn owl cannot even hoot or call as other owls do; it makes more of a rasping noise.

I couldn't find much information about owl syringes (plural of syrinx; gotta love Latin). Apparently they are not as interesting as the voice boxes of other birds.  But I did find some videos of owl calls.

Here's a video with recordings of barred owl calls.  I don't think you get the sense of volume, but imagine that this recording was made about a mile or two away from where the owl is roosting.

Now here are some calls of several different types of owls. What I love about this and about the barred owl calls above is the variety of voices. Not only do the calls sound different from one species to the next, but they sound different from one individual owl to the next.

Parting Thoughts

Just as no two sunsets are alike, possibly no two birds' songs are alike.  Though birds can sing way better than people can, they are like people in that each bird's voice is unique.

So I may never again hear a bird's song like what I heard the other day.  But I may hear another song some other day that is even more wonderful.

Maybe what I heard was actually a robin. Everybody thinks they're so common, and they are, but I do love them. They remind me of long, good summer days when I was young and spent most of the day playing outside and the sun has gone down and I'm lying in bed, tired in a good way, being lulled to sleep by the soft breeze from the fan, while outside, the robins are singing their good-night songs. No better lullaby.

Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Indigo Bunting
Audubon, Indigo Bunting
The Guardian, Mystery bird: Indigo bunting, Passerina cyanea
British Library, The language of birds 6. How does a bird sing?
Wingmasters, Who Gives a Hoot -- and Who Doesn't
Frank B. Gill, Ornithology p 223


  1. Khi thị trường dịch thuật ở nước ta ngày càng trở nên sôi động và phát triển mạnh về số lượng như vậy, các doanh nghiệp có nhu cầu sử dụng dịch vụ dịch thuật cảm thấy bối rối khi không biết đâu mới là những công ty dịch thuật uy tín nhất Việt Nam? trong trường hợp này, lựa chọn dịch vụ của ; dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp - MIDtrans một công ty dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp có trụ sở tại 01 Tây Sơn, Nam Lý, Đồng Hới, Quảng Bình là sự lựa chọn sáng suốt.
    Chúng tôi cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật đa ngôn ngữ: Anh, Trung, Pháp, Nhật, Hàn Quốc, Đức, Nga, Tây Ban Nha, Bồ Đào Nha, Ý, Hà Lan, Ả-rập, Iran, Séc, Thụy Điển, Đan Mạch, Ba Lan, La Tinh, Hungari, Bungari, Slovakia, Ukraina, Lào, Campuchia, Thái Lan, Myanma, Philipin, Indonesia, Malaysia, Hán Nôm và các ngôn ngữ khác.
    Quý khách hàng có nhu câu biên dịch, phiên dịch vui lòng liên hệ
    Công ty dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp MIDtrans
    ĐC: 01 Tây Sơn, Nam Lý, Đồng Hới, Quảng Bình
    ĐT: 0963918438

    Macaw Parrots For Sale Text or call +1(512) 598-8125
    Hello, and welcome to our website for the best hand raised macaw parrots for sale.
    We pride ourselves in the best taming practices of macaws among aviaries.
    All of our macaws are bred in a disease-free Biosecure breeding sanctuary.
    They are well socialized, having been raised in our home as members of our
    own family in order for them to become ready to be a member of yours.
    They are quite comfortable around all ages, including the elderly and young children.
    When you purchase a bird from Us, we are committed to offering lifetime support and guidance to you and your family.

    Hand Raised Parrots for Sale, Macaw Parrots for Sale
    Macaws are playful and active and they have excited personalities to go along with their sizes.
    But this also makes them very challenging pets. They do have the ability to say words and mimic
    our speech but it is not as clear as some other pet bird species.
    Because they are so intelligent, macaws can be trained. You can start when your pet bird is young,
    and work on hand-feeding, teaching your bird to talk or sing, and training your macaw not to nip, bite, or scream.
    Text or call +1(512) 598-8125

    Macaw Parrots For Sale

    blue macaw for sale

    blue and goald macaw breeder

    Scarlet Macaw

    defferent types of macaw available for sale

    blue headed macaw for sale

    parrots for sale

    macaw for sale near me

    red bellied macaw

    Text or call +1(512) 598-8125

  3. Excellent post. This article is very helpful for people and also for me. I get some useful knowledge in this post. Thanks for sharing the informative topic, by the way... Top 10 Digital Marketing Institute in Delhi | Top Digital Marketing Institute in Delhi | Marketing Courses in Delhi | Best Digital Marketing Training in Delhi

  4. You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers.
    Singing Classes in Delhi | Fashion Designing Course in Delhi | Makeup Course in Delhi | Event Management Course in Delhi | Interior Design Course in Delhi

  5. Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for the informative post. Stock Market Courses in Delhi

  6. Diet Plan

    for Weight Loss
    . A healthy eating plan gives your body the

    nutrients it needs every day while staying within daily calorie goal

    for weight loss.

  7. Myasthenia Gravis Natural Remedies help to cure diseases, natural remedies have been arranged for all the aims and purposes of Myasthenia Gravis. Herbal Supplement for Myasthenia Gravis substitution on myasthenia gravis recover the tissues and muscles issues, and we present this case to build mindfulness and animate exploration.

  8. If you are a student who is unable to create assignments then search for the best Assignment Help services. Choose the one by reading the reviews of their clients. It will give you a clear idea of the services they provide.

  9. Wow! Informative post. Searching for an Assignment helper Saudi Arabia? Visit our website to get professional-level assistance from the experts. They will be doing everything for building your project from the scratch.

  10. Don't worry if you have trouble writing a unique Ignou MAPC project. Our project writing experts team will help you in creating unique, high-quality projects in a short time. This will save you a lot of time. Many students spend a lot of time trying to compose their Ignou MAPC Solved Assignment 2021 22. Ignousynopsis experienced writers will ensure that your work is error-free. This will help you make sure your work is error-free and earn high grades for your project work.

  11. How to get cheaper POE Currency? Of course, players have to buy POE Currency during Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday trading platform activities. POECurrency will offer a 6% discount on Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday, the discount code is "Friday".

    Attached link:

  12. You can easily Buy Assignment Online from us we have provided the order now link for the assignment. You are suggested to check the complete details of the same from this page and contact us accordingly.

  13. Hard to ignore such an amazing article like this. You really amazed me with your writing talent. Thank you for sharing again.

  14. Nice shared; I enjoyed surfing from this blog. I'm supper immensely thankful for the learning this inspiring information from this page. Thanks so much for sharing. Visit crescent university school fees schedule for new students

  15. This nutritious fruit offers multiple health benefits. Apples may lower your chance of developing cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. Research says apples may also help you lose weight while improving your gut and brain health. Apples are the most widely consumed fruit globally.

    I really appreciated
    Thank you for sharing your blog its very useful and informational blog for us.

    IFDA is the best institute for Graphic design Course in Delhi. We also provide 100% Job Placement and Paid Internship.
    Best Graphic Design course in Delhi

  16. I just wanted to take a moment to say thank you for your exceptional blog posts. Your insights are always enlightening. Keep up the great work! Daniel Dantas


If you're a spammer, there's no point posting a comment. It will automatically get filtered out or deleted. Comments from real people, however, are always very welcome!